About Me

My photo
With more than 50 years of travelling about in India, one can share a good deal of information and experience about out-of-the-way places and roads less travelled. That can make visits all the more exciting and enjoyable.

Monday 21 September 2020

India Current Affairs - the Sino-Indian Border Conflict

 Ever since the latest series of Sino-Indian border frictions started in May 2020, this has been much debated and discussed on the media. Even a couple of days ago, an overseas specialist who has done research on this topic implied in a major newspaper interview that the border problem is a product of British thoughtlessness in the matter. 


To cross-check I went back to my book "A Conflict in Thin Air" published in 2016 by Cinnamon Teal Publishing. In this I could identify the treaties between India and Tibet or China on the following occasions - (a) Between Kashmir (then under the  Maharaja, Gulab Singh) and Tibet in 1842, (b) Between Ladakh and Tibet in 1852, (c) the Cheffo Convention between Britain and China in 1876, (d) British India and China Treaty of 1890 setting out the configuration of the Tibet-Sikkim border, (e) the Simla Agreement of April 1914, which China signed and then repudiated and (f) the India-China Agreement on border trade in 1954. As to specifically about an understanding or appreciation about the  border, I can only refer the scholar concerned to the several maps that British India produced from 1840s to 1890s, especially about Ladakh. At least 3 or 4 attempts were made by British India to have the Chinese authorities to agree to joint surveys from 1870s to 1920s but to no avail.



All these records are available in the India Office Library in London, and references will be found in the books by Dr. Alastair Lamb , Dorothy Woodman and others. To paraphrase Shakespeare in the play "Julius Caesar" -- "The fault, dear China, lies not in our stars, but within you". 


No comments:

Post a Comment