India Current Affairs - the Sino-Indian Border Conflict

 Ever since the latest series of Sino-Indian border frictions started in May 2020, this has been much debated and discussed on the media. Even a couple of days ago, an overseas specialist who has done research on this topic implied in a major newspaper interview that the border problem is a product of British thoughtlessness in the matter. 

To cross-check I went back to my book "A Conflict in Thin Air" published in 2016 by Cinnamon Teal Publishing. In this I could identify the treaties between India and Tibet or China on the following occasions - (a) Between Kashmir (then under the  Maharaja, Gulab Singh) and Tibet in 1842, (b) Between Ladakh and Tibet in 1852, (c) the Cheffo Convention between Britain and China in 1876, (d) British India and China Treaty of 1890 setting out the configuration of the Tibet-Sikkim border, (e) the Simla Agreement of April 1914, which China signed and then repudiated and (f) the India-China Agreement on border trade in 1954. As to specifically about an understanding or appreciation about the  border, I can only refer the scholar concerned to the several maps that British India produced from 1840s to 1890s, especially about Ladakh. At least 3 or 4 attempts were made by British India to have the Chinese authorities to agree to joint surveys from 1870s to 1920s but to no avail.

All these records are available in the India Office Library in London, and references will be found in the books by Dr. Alastair Lamb , Dorothy Woodman and others. To paraphrase Shakespeare in the play "Julius Caesar" -- "The fault, dear China, lies not in our stars, but within you". 

Sino-Indian Border Conflict: a Historical Perspective - I

Excerpts from the book "A Conflict in Thin Air",on the Sino-Indian border conflict, published in 2016 by CinnamonTeal Publishing (also available through Amazon) --  

"Tibet, a vast plateau at an average height of more than twelve thousand feet altitude in most places, straddles a large chunk of Asia, bounded by the Himalayan mountain ranges to the south and pierced in places by high passes like Lanak La, Shipki La, Mana, along the Himachal Pradesh-Tibet and the Kumaon-Tibet borders respectively, the passes in Nepal, and Nathu La, and Jelep La in the Sikkim Himalayas. The Karakoram mountain range stands guard to the southwest of Tibet, the Kuen Lun range on the west, the Koko-nor area and vast alkaline marshes on the north east and, a rugged tangle of hills and forests mostly between ten and fifteen thousand feet on the east bordering Yunnan and Szechuan provinces of China................Over the last thousand years or so, traders from Kashmir, Bushairis from Himachal Pradesh, Bhutias from Kumaon, and the Nepalese and Bhutanese traded across the high mountain passes for wool, salt (Tibet having many saline springs and lakes), gold, borax and so on, while the Chinese traders via Yunnan brought in great quantities of black tea that the Tibetans were inordinately fond of. In turn, Tibetan traders came with their wares of gold, silver, leather, and of course wool, into the marts of India and China (Tibetans were bringing their goods-laden mule trains to trade into Kalimpong in the Darjeeling hills in India via Jelep La as late as 1950s).

A view of typical Ladakh landscape

Pangong Lake in Ladakh - scene of recent skirmishes

I had visited Ladakh for sight-seeing in June 2013 and that as well as a chance discussion with a friend set me off to know more about the Sino-Indian border conflict. It took me over 2 years of research and going through about 70 books and several maps to get a grip on the subject. This resulted in my book on the Sino-Indian border conflict that is mentioned above.

Excerpt -- "At the core lay the long-standing Sino-Tibetan animosities of over a thousand years. And,  the persistent attempts of Tibet to assert its independence with the equally persistent efforts by successive Chinese administrations to enjoy the fruits of Mongol and Manchu imperialism since the mid-13^th century in Tibet, Sinkiang and Mongolia. Added to this was the ups and downs of Tibetan and Chinese administration in the respective countries since the 17^th century (including outbreak of civil wars in the two countries), the advances made by European and British imperialism in both China and India, the Sino-Russian tussles in Mongolia, and of course, the “Great Game” between Britain and Russia............... There have been quite a few books on the Sino-Indian conflict of 1962, such as those by Neville Maxwell, Karunakar Gupta, S.R. Johri and John Garvin (amongst others, besides those by Dalvi and Kaul) fairly well-known to the Indian reading public. But, as my studies revealed, there were many, many others, drawing upon extremely valuable archives and records that, together with some basic histories of China and Tibet, help provide valuable insights and perspectives on the whole issue of the “Why?” of it. I have seen those records through the eyes and pens of renowned scholars such as Dr. Alastair Lamb, Dorothy Woodman, Margaret Fisher and her co-authors, Parshotam Mehra, and those of much earlier days, such as Charles Bell, E. Teichman, Robert Reid, T. Richardson, L. Petech, and many others, whose names have been mentioned in the Bibliography. Added to those should be the known and unknown surveyors of those border areas, whose maps with their wealth of details are a joy to behold."

This brief introduction to the geography and history of Tibet and China should help in a better understanding of the issues. The book of course gives a fuller exposition.